I. N. H. S. C O M M I T T E E
Killultagh, Old Rock & Chichester (F) Point to Point Meeting, Friday 20th April, 2012.
Maiden Race for 6-y-o & upwards Mares
The Stewards interviewed Mr. G Yemm, rider of “Corrag Lass” concerning the use of the whip in this race.
Having considered evidence from Mr. Yemm, rider, and from Mr. T.L. Crawford, I.N.H.S. Representative the Stewards decided that Mr. Yemm was in breach of Regulation 58 2 (f) in that he had used his whip with excessive force and frequency. They therefore suspended Mr. Yemm for five Point to Point days having taken his previous record into account
I. N. H. S. C O M M I T T E E
Doneraile (F) Point to Point Meeting, Sunday 22nd April, 2012.
Open Lightweight Race for Novice Riders
The Stewards enquired into possible interference approximately fifty yards from the line involving "Annacarton", placed second, ridden by Ms. J.M. Mangan, and "Sir Frederick", placed first, ridden by Mr. S. O'Connor.
Evidence was heard from the riders concerned and having considered the evidence the Stewards decided that they would make no alteration to the Judges placings. The Stewards cautioned Mr. O'Connor towards his responsibilities in his use of the whip in future.
The following trainers were fined €200 in each case for the non-notification of a Veterinary Certificate in accordance with the provisions of Rule 194 (v) (vi):- Mr. Adrian McGuinness for Cookie Crumbles (injured loading) at Dundalk on 13th April 2012; Mr. Gordon Elliott for Musawama (stone bruise) at Tramore on 14th April and Mr. Eoin Doyle for Little Return (lame) at Tramore on 15th April.
Turf Club and I.N.H.S. Committee
The Licensing Committee Mrs. C. Corballis (in the Chair), Mr. P.N. Reynolds, Mr. M. Morris and Mr. T.L. Crawford met at The Offices of The Turf Club, The Curragh, Co. Kildare on Thursday, 19th April, 2012 and considered a breach of the conditions under which a licence was granted in relation to insurance. Severe warnings and fines were issued to the following Trainers: Mr. David Anthony O’Brien €200 and Mr. Michael Croke €800.
Limerick Meeting, 1st April 2012 (1st Race)
The Chief Executive of the Turf Club has investigated the background to the withdrawal of ‘Roman Cavalery’ from the Family Fun Day (C&G) Maiden Hurdle at Limerick on 1st April 2012 due to a passport irregularity.
On the day in question the trainer’s representative Mr. Michael Gunn told the Stewards that there was a passport irregularity and that the connections did not want to run the horse until the issue was resolved. He further informed the Stewards that the Turf Club was already aware of the situation, having been informed by the trainer.
Following an investigation, it was discovered that the trainer’s contact was with Horse Racing Ireland and not the Turf Club. Horse Racing Ireland has confirmed that the trainer, M.F. Morris rang its Registrations Department on Friday afternoon (prior to the day of racing at Limerick) to say that the name for this horse had been spelt wrong but that the horse had already run in Point-to-Points. Horse Racing Ireland subsequently checked the original naming form and realised that both Weatherbys and Horse Racing Ireland had spelt the name incorrectly and that a correction would have to be published in the Irish Racing Calendar, including the lines of form. M.F. Morris decided that he would not run the horse until the error was corrected and the spelling of the horse’s name changed to the correct spelling ‘Roman Cavalry’.
In view of the above it is not necessary to take any further action and the matter is now concluded.
Dundalk Meeting, 18th April 2012
The Stewards fined the following trainer €200 in respect of his non-runner: Mr. J. Larkin for House Limit (off feed).
079A Irish Stallion Farms European Breeders Fund Fillies Maiden & The Stewards interviewed D.P. McDonogh, rider of Anklet, unplaced, concerning his use of the whip.
Evidence was heard from the rider concerned.
Having viewed a recording of the race and considered the evidence, the Stewards were of the opinion that D.P. McDonogh was in breach of Regulation 10 2(b), in that he continued to use the whip after his chance of winning or being placed had clearly gone. Having taken his good record into account, the Stewards therefore severely cautioned him concerning his future responsibilities in this regard.
079B Dundalk Stadium On Facebook Maiden & F.M. Berry, rider of Danehill Promise, trained by Mr. J.A. Nash, reported to the Stewards' Secretaries that his mount ran green turning into the straight.
079C Hen & Stag Packages At Dundalk Stadium Handicap & W.J. Lee, rider of Feathers And Bows (USA), trained by Mr. David Wachman, reported to the Stewards' Secretaries that his mount was unable to get a clear run in the straight, but stayed on well in the closing stages.
079D Irish Stallion Farms European Breeders Fund Fillies Maiden & The Stewards received a report from Mr. J.R. Banahan, Turf Club Starter, concerning the delay to the start of this race.
Evidence was heard from Mr. Banahan, who stated that the start of this race was four minutes late. He explained that both of Mr. A.P. O’Brien’s runners arrived at the start well behind all the other horses, which contributed to the delay in proceedings.
Evidence was subsequently heard from Mr. Pat Keating, representing Mr A.P. O’Brien, trainer, who stated that while he accepted that the two horses left the parade ring last, he was not aware of the fact that they arrived at the start that late. He added that one of the fillies was making her racecourse debut and that he was anxious for them to make their way nice and slowly to the start.
Having considered the evidence, the Stewards severely cautioned Mr O’Brien, through his representative, concerning his future responsibilities to avoid delaying the start. He was also advised to request permission in future if he needs to leave the parade ring late or walk to the start with any horse that he has concerns about.
079E Follow Dundalk On Facebook Handicap & K.J. Manning, rider of Miracle Cure, trained by Mr. J.S. Bolger, reported to the Stewards' Secretaries that his mount ran flat. The Turf Club Veterinary Officer reported to the Stewards that Miracle Cure was found to be post race normal.
079H Dundalk Stadium Handicap & The Stewards enquired into an incident in the straight involving Engage The Dance, ridden by N.G. McCullagh, and Another Duchess (GB), ridden by S. Foley, both unplaced, after it appeared that the latter had to check.
Evidence was heard from the riders concerned.
Having viewed a recording of the race and considered the evidence, the Stewards were of the opinion that the incident was accidental in nature and took no further action.
S. Foley, rider of Another Duchess (GB), trained by Mr. A.L.T. Moore, reported to the Stewards' Secretaries that his mount suffered slight interference in the straight before staying on in the closing stages.
Tipperary Meeting, 19th April 2012
080B Follow Tipperary On Facebook Handicap & B.A. Curtis, rider of Royal Becky, trained by Mr. Martin Brassil, reported to the Stewards' Secretaries that his mount was found to have a burst blood vessel post race. This was confirmed to the Stewards by the Turf Club Veterinary Officer.
080D(i) Follow @ Tipperary Races On Twitter Maiden Hurdle (Division One) & The Stewards enquired into possible interference at the final hurdle involving the winner Mobile Sizer (GB), ridden by A.E. Lynch, and Sir Lynx, ridden by Andrew J. McNamara, placed second, after it appeared that the latter suffered interference.
Evidence was heard from the riders concerned.
Having viewed a recording of the race and considered the evidence, the Stewards were of the opinion that whilst Mobile Sizer (GB) did interfere with Sir Lynx, they were not satisfied that the winner had improved its finishing position as a result of this interference. The Stewards therefore made no alteration to the the Judge’s placing. Futhermore, the Stewards felt the interference was accidental in nature and therefore took no further action.
Mr. E. Irwin, trainee Acting Steward was present at this enquiry.
Mr. John Powell, Acting Steward absented himself from this enquiry.
H.G. Murphy, rider of Ki (GB), trained by Mr. John Joseph Murphy, reported to the Stewards' Secretaries that his mount jumped poorly and hung throughout.
080D(ii) Follow @ Tipperary Races On Twitter Maiden Hurdle (Division Two) & M. Darcy, rider of Munster Fusilier, trained by Mr. Kieran P. Cotter, reported to the Stewards' Secretaries that his mount was pulled up lame.
The Turf Club Veterinary Officer reported to the Stewards that An Dearthair Og, trained by Mr. Henry De Bromhead, was found to be post race normal.
080E Schooling At Tipperary Maiden Hurdle & Mr. John J. Walsh, trainer of Andunowhat, reported to the Stewards' Secretaries that his charge never travelled on today’s ground.
Mr. P.W. Mullins, rider of Bowfinger, trained by Mr. W.P. Mullins, reported to the Stewards' Secretaries that his mount made a bad mistake and never recovered.
D.J. Condon, rider of Castlerock Rose, trained by Mr. D. Rohan, reported to the Stewards' Secretaries that his mount was found to have a burst blood vessel post race.
H.D. Dunne, rider of Mrs Trair, trained by Mr. Colin Bowe, reported to the Stewards' Secretaries that his mount gurgled in running.
Ms. Claire O’Connell, trainer of End Zone, reported to the Stewards' Secretaries that her charge was found to be lame on his left fore post race. This was confirmed to the Stewards by the Turf Club Veterinary Officer.
080F Tipperaryraces.com Hanidcap Hurdle & The Stewards enquired into the running and riding of Bean Chroi Bhriste, placed fourth, ridden by P.W. Flood, and trained by Mr. M. Flannery.
Evidence was heard from the rider and trainer concerned.
In his evidence P.W. Flood stated that his instructions were to ride his mount on her own and not in amongst horses, as she is claustrophobic and to take things from there and finish as best as he could. He said the field went quick and he dropped his mount out at the rear of the field. He said going down the back straight he let his mount fill her lungs and she started to take hold of the bit and passed a number of tiring horses. Turning in, he said he had to let the mare fill her lungs again. He said at that stage his intention was to try and finish in third position with a strong drive after jumping the last. He said he did that to the best of his ability, but his mount just failed to take third place. He felt if he got after his mount earlier in the straight she may not have got home and may not have even finished fourth.
In his evidence Mr. Flannery confirmed the instructions and expressed satisfaction with the ride. He said it was the mare’s first run after a break and she was as fit as he could get her at home. He said the mare had run well once before when held up, but turned sour after trying to make the running in some of her races. He said he felt she may benefit from being held up today, as she seems to like passing horses. He said he had no plans for her, but that on the advice of his rider after this race, he may consider running her in a higher grade handicap with a lower weight after she carried top weight today.
The Stewards also received a report from the Turf Club Veterinary Officer, which stated that Bean Chroi Bhriste was found to be post race normal.
Having viewed a recording of the race and considered the evidence, the Stewards noted the explanations offered.
Mr. E. Irwin, trainee Acting Steward, attended this enquiry.
P.T. Enright, rider of Jack Absolute, trained by Mr. John J. Walsh, reported to the Stewards' Secretaries that his mount never travelled and was therefore pulled up.
B.T. O’Connell, rider of Miss Xian, trained by Mr. F. Flood, reported to the Stewards' Secretaries that his mount never travelled and was therefore pulled up.
080G Tipperary Racecourse Events I.N.H. Flat Race & Mr. J.P. Magnier, rider of On A High, trained by Mr. T.J. Taaffe, reported to the Stewards' Secretaries that his mount was pulled up lame.
Miss Elizabeth Doyle, trainer of Within Reason, reported to the Stewards' Secretaries that her charge choked in running.
The Stewards fined Mr. M.F. Morris, trainer, €130 for lodging a passport in respect of Roman Cavarly, in which the vaccinations did not conform with the provisions of Rule 91. The Stewards allowed the horse to run on receipt of the trainer’s written assurance that the vaccinations were in order.
Wexford Meeting, 20th April 2012
The Stewards authorised the following substitutions of riders at this meeting: The following riders replaced J.R. Barry (injured):- B.M. Cash rode The Rossmeister, trained by Mr. Eoin Doyle (fifth race) and P.A. Gallagher rode Bold Present, trained by Mr. Leonard Whitmore (sixth race); M.J. Ferris rode Cluain Easa (reserve), trained by Mr. S.G. Walsh (first race); A.E. Lynch rode My Brother Pat (reserve), trained by Mr. Henry de Bromhead (third race); D.J. Bates replaced H.G. Murphy on Razorlite (See report), trained by Mr. Denis W. Cullen (fourth race); B. Hayes rode Red Memo (reserve), trained by Mr. Leonard Whitmore (fifth race) and Mr. D. Roche rode Dreaming On (reserve), trained by Mr. Eoin Doyle (seventh race).
081B Black Point Handicap Hurdle & The Stewards requested a report from Mr. Thomas Foley, trainer of the winner Golanbrook, regarding the apparent improvement in form of his charge compared with the horse’s previous run at Cork on the 8th April where he finished 12th of 14 finishers and was beaten 67 lengths by the winner Carrigmartin.
Mr. Foley reported that his charge likes to dictate in his races, but the animal was not as handy as he would have liked at Cork and switched himself off. On this occasion, however, the horse returned to his familiar tactic of dictating matters and this had the desired effect.
Having considered the report, the Stewards noted the content.
T.J. Doyle, rider of Viaduct Bud, trained by Mr. Terence O’Brien, reported to the Stewards' Secretaries that his mount appeared to lose his action in the straight and was therefore pulled up. He also said that the horse felt sound when dismounted. The Turf Club Veterinary Officer reported to the Stewards that Viaduct Bud was found to be post race normal.
081D Oysters Point Handicap Hurdle & The Stewards received a report stating that H.G. Murphy, rider, would be unable to fulfil his riding engagement on Razorlite in this race as he experienced transport difficulties en route. The Stewards therefore allowed the substitution of D.J. Bates and fined H.G. Murphy €200.
The Stewards requested a report from Mr. Oliver McKiernan, trainer of the winner Whatever Jacksays, regarding the apparent improvement in form of his charge compared with the horse’s previous run at Fairyhouse on the 8th April where he finished 11th of 18th finishers and was beaten 30 lengths by the winner Archie Meade.
Mr. McKiernan reported that his charge benefited from the quicker ground and the drop in class of race today. He added that his charge was able to repel all challenges today compared to the stronger race at Fairyhouse on good ground when he was unable to take any advantage.
Having considered the report, the Stewards noted the content.
081E Black Point Beginners Steeplechase & B. Hayes, rider of Red Memo, trained by Mr. Leonard Whitmore, reported to the Stewards' Secretaries that his mount made jumping errors and also made a respiratory noise at the third last fence. He also reported that he had to hold his mount together in the latter stages.
081F Broomhill Point Handicap Steeplechase & B.J. Cooper, rider of Talab (GB), trained by Mr. D.T. Hughes, reported to the Stewards' Secretaries that his mount ran flat throughout.
A.D. Leigh, rider of More Chimney’s, trained by Mr. W.J. Austin, reported to the Stewards' Secretaries that his mount was pulled up injured. The Turf Club Veterinary Officer reported to the Stewards that More Chimney’s was found to be lame post race.
Naas Meeting, 21st April 2012
082A Naas Median Auction Maiden & The Stewards informed Mr. Patrick O. Brady, trainer of Colla Pier, that his charge would have to be re-certified before being declared to run from stalls again.
P.J. Smullen, rider of Acorn Valley, trained by Mr. D.K. Weld, reported to the Stewards' Secretaries that his mount hung badly throughout.
082B Naas Racecourse On Facebook Rated Race & The Turf Club Veterinary Officer reported to the Stewards that Rigoletta, trained by Mr. J.S. Bolger, was found to be post race normal.
082C Tipper Road Apprentice Handicap & The Stewards enquired into the falls of An Mhi, ridden by Kate McGivern, and Can We Dare, ridden by D.M. Sweeney, which occurred inside the four furlong pole.
Evidence was heard from the riders concerned.
In her evidence Kate McGivern stated that she was watching what was happening ahead of her when her mount stumbled and fell independently for no apparent reason.
In his evidence D.M. Sweeney stated that he unavoidably collided with An Mhi and became unseated.
Having viewed a recording of the race and considered the evidence, the Stewards were satisfied that the incident was accidental in nature and took no further action.
082E goracingatnaasracecourse.com Maiden & The Stewards enquired into possible interference inside the final furlong involving the winner Royal Visit, ridden by J.P. Murtagh, Srucahan, ridden by C.D. Hayes, placed second, Atacx, ridden by W.M. Lordan, placed third, and Steely Grace, ridden by S. Foley, placed fifth.
Evidence was heard from the riders concerned.
Having viewed a recording of the race and considered the evidence, the Stewards made no alteration to the Judge’s placings. The Stewards were, however, of the opinion that C.D. Hayes had ridden carelessly and having taken his previous record in this regard into account, they therefore suspended him for two race days.
W.J. Lee, rider of Step Lightly, trained by Mr. David Wachman, reported to the Stewards' Secretaries that his mount continuously changed her legs, ran green and stayed on in the closing stages.
F. Lynch, rider of September Lily, trained by Mr. W. McCreery, reported to the Stewards' Secretaries that his mount ran freely to the start.
082G Summer Barbeque Evenings Handicap & The Stewards requested a report from Mr. Andrew Oliver, trainer of the winner Bankroll (GB), regarding the apparent improvement in form of his charge compared with the horse’s previous run at Leopardstown on the 15th April, where he finished 11th of 18 runners and was beaten 10 lengths by the winner Olfa.
Mr. Oliver reported that his charge was standing in stalls for a long period at Leopardstown and became agitated. He said that the horse then missed the break, but hit the front before the turn in and then faded. He felt that today’s better ground compared to the quick surface at Leopardstown was a contributing factor, while he also felt that his horse got the run of the race today.
Having considered the report, the Stewards noted the content.
Curragh Meeting, 22nd April 2012
The Stewards fined the following trainer €200 in respect of his non-runner: Mr. Jarlath P. Fahey for Balladiene (withdrawn – lame).
083B Irish Field Handicap & The Stewards enquired into possible interference inside the final furlong involving the winner Cnocan Diva, ridden by S.A. Gray, Susiescot, ridden by L.F. Roche, placed second, Boom To Bust, ridden by E.J. McNamara, placed third, Winning Impact, ridden by S.H. James, placed fourth, Luan Cincise, ridden by K.J. Manning, placed fifth, New Magic, ridden by N.G. McCullagh and Maggie The Cat, ridden by W.M. Lordan, both unplaced.
Evidence was heard from the riders concerned in the presence of Mr. James Stack, representing Mr. T. Stack, trainer, who accompanied S.A. Gray in the Stewards Room.
Having viewed a recording of the race and considered the evidence, the Stewards were of the opinion that while interference had occurred, they were not satisfied that the winner had improved his finishing position as a result of that interference. The Stewards therefore made no alteration to the Judge’s placings. They were, however, of the opinion that S.A. Gray was in breach of Rule 214, in that he had ridden carelessly. Having taken his record in this regard into account, the Stewards therefore suspended him for two race days (6th and 7th May). Furthermore the Stewards cautioned S.A. Gray concerning the accuracy of his evidence.
Mrs. T.K. Cooper, Acting Steward, absented herself from this enquiry.
083D Big Bad Bob Gladness Stakes & F.M. Berry, rider of Beacon Lodge, trained by Mr. David Nicholls (in GB), reported to the Stewards' Secretaries that his mount ran too free. The Turf Club Veterinary Officer reported to the Stewards that Beacon Lodge was found to be blowing hard post race.
083E Run Kildare 13th May Alleged Stakes & The Turf Club Veterinary Officer reported to the Stewards that Zaminast (GB), trained by Mr. D.K. Weld, was found to be post race normal.
083H 3 For 2 Ticket Offer At curragh.ie Handicap & J.P. Murtagh, rider of Bombadero, trained by Mr. Denis W. Cullen, reported to the Stewards' Secretaries that his mount lost his action in this race.